Skip to main content
Raghavan & VaradhanChartered Accountants

GST

Where input tax credit actually goes missing

Most credit that a business loses is not disallowed by an officer. It quietly fails to appear in GSTR-2B and nobody notices until the annual return.

Meenakshi Sundaresan6 min read

Section 16(2)(aa) of the CGST Act made a quiet change with large consequences: credit is available only if the supplier has reported the invoice and it appears in the recipient's auto-generated statement. The practical effect is that a buyer's entitlement now depends on a third party's filing discipline. A business can hold a valid tax invoice, have paid the supplier in full, and still be unable to take the credit.

The four common failure modes

In reviewing purchase registers against GSTR-2B, the same four patterns account for the overwhelming majority of mismatches.

  • The supplier filed GSTR-1 late, so the invoice lands in the following month's statement. Credit is not lost, but it is deferred — and if the deferral straddles a financial year end, it can be lost entirely.
  • The supplier reported the invoice against the wrong GSTIN. This is common where a group has multiple state registrations and the vendor master holds only one.
  • The invoice was reported as B2C rather than B2B, usually because the purchase order carried no GSTIN. The credit does not appear at all.
  • The place of supply was determined differently by the two parties, so IGST appears where CGST and SGST were expected, or the reverse.

Why annual reconciliation is too late

The outer limit for claiming credit for a financial year is the earlier of 30 November of the following year or the date of filing the annual return. A mismatch discovered while preparing GSTR-9C in December is therefore usually beyond remedy. Worse, the supplier's own window for amending GSTR-1 has closed by then, so even a cooperative vendor cannot fix it.

A monthly reconciliation moves the discovery point to within about six weeks of the transaction, when the supplier can still amend and when commercial leverage still exists — the payment is often not yet released.

A workable monthly routine

  • Download GSTR-2B on the 15th, after the GSTR-1 due date has passed for monthly filers.
  • Match on invoice number, date, GSTIN and taxable value — not on value alone, which produces false matches on round-figure invoices.
  • Split the exceptions into three lists: in books but not in 2B, in 2B but not in books, and matched with a value or tax-head difference.
  • Send the first list to the affected suppliers the same week, with the invoice details, rather than a generic reminder.
  • Hold payment release against unreconciled invoices where the contract permits it. This single control resolves more mismatches than all the follow-up correspondence combined.

The vendor master is the root cause

Recurring mismatches with the same supplier almost always trace back to a stale vendor master — a GSTIN captured at onboarding and never revised, a supplier who has since migrated to a composition scheme, or a registration that has been cancelled. An annual re-verification of GSTINs against the public search facility takes a few hours and removes a category of problem rather than an instance of it.

Material published on this site is general in nature and reflects the position on the date of publication. It is not professional advice and should not be acted upon without a review of your specific facts.

Next step

Start with a conversation about where you stand.

A short scoping call, no obligation either way. If we are not the right fit for what you need, we will say so and point you somewhere sensible.