Before the 2021 restructuring, a notice under section 148 could issue on the assessing officer's recorded reasons alone. The assessee's first opportunity to respond came after the reassessment had been set in motion. Section 148A inserted a preliminary stage that must be completed first, and the requirements of that stage are specific enough to be tested.
The sequence
- The officer must have information suggesting that income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment. Information is a defined term, not an open category.
- A show cause notice must be served giving the assessee an opportunity to explain why a notice under section 148 should not issue, with a period of not less than seven days.
- The material relied upon must be supplied with that notice. A notice that refers to information without disclosing it does not put the assessee in a position to respond.
- The officer must consider the reply and pass a speaking order deciding whether it is a fit case for issue of notice.
- Only then can the notice under section 148 issue, and only within the applicable time limit.
Where the procedure most often breaks down
In practice, three defects recur. The first is a show cause notice that recites a conclusion rather than the information — for example, that the assessee has entered into transactions with a party found to be non-genuine, without identifying the transactions or the finding. The second is an order under section 148A(d) that reproduces the notice and adds a sentence stating that the reply has been considered, without engaging with what the reply said. The third is a time limit issue: the extended period is available only where the escaped income is represented by an asset or expenditure and crosses the monetary threshold, and the order must record how that threshold is met.
What to do with the seven days
The reply at this stage matters more than its length suggests. It is the only document on record before the officer forms a view, and it frames every subsequent proceeding. Three things belong in it.
- A factual account of the transaction with supporting documents, filed at the earliest stage rather than held back for appeal.
- Where the information supplied is incomplete, a specific request for the material relied upon — recorded, so that the failure to supply it becomes part of the record.
- Where the limitation period is in question, the computation set out explicitly rather than asserted.
An extension of the seven-day period is usually granted where a reasoned request is made within the period. Allowing the period to lapse and responding to the section 148 notice instead surrenders the only opportunity to prevent the proceeding rather than defend it.
Material published on this site is general in nature and reflects the position on the date of publication. It is not professional advice and should not be acted upon without a review of your specific facts.